When a Commission Dies and You Still Get Paid

When a Commission Dies and You Still Get Paid

Understanding how kill fees work in commissions.

I remember sitting in a cramped, drafty corner of a London cafe in 2004, staring at an email from an editor that essentially said, “We love the direction, but the board has decided to pivot, so we won’t be needing the rest of the chapters.” There was no apology, no mention of the forty hours I’d already poured into that manuscript, and certainly no check in the mail. That was my first real lesson in the industry: if you don’t understand how kill fees work, you aren’t a professional; you’re a volunteer. Most people treat these fees like a polite tip for your troubles, but that’s a lie that keeps freelancers broke and working for free.

In this post, I’m stripping away the polite euphemisms to tell you how to actually protect your income. I’m going to walk you through the math of a cancellation, how to bake these protections into your initial contract, and exactly what to say when a client tries to ghost you mid-project. No fluff, no “manifesting” more work—just the hard numbers and legal realities you need to ensure that when a project dies, your bank account doesn’t.

Standard Kill Fee Percentages the Cost of Wasted Labor

Standard Kill Fee Percentages the Cost of Wasted Labor

When you sit down to negotiate your next project, you aren’t just discussing the final deliverable; you are negotiating the cost of your time if the floor drops out from under the client. In my twenty-one years, I’ve seen too many writers walk away from a half-finished manuscript with nothing but a “thank you for your hard work” email. To avoid this, your freelance contract termination clauses must be explicit about the math.

Generally, standard kill fee percentages scale with the progress of the work. If a client pulls the plug during the initial research phase, a 25% fee is a fair way of protecting freelance income for the hours already logged. However, if you have already delivered a completed first draft and the project dies due to a change in their marketing direction, you shouldn’t be settling for pennies. At that stage, I typically insist on 50% to 75% of the total project fee. You aren’t being difficult; you are simply ensuring that wasted labor is compensated before the invoice is closed for good.

Protecting Freelance Income When the Client Flinches

Protecting Freelance Income When the Client Flinches

If you wait until the client sends the “we’ve decided to go in a different direction” email to start talking about money, you’ve already lost. Most people treat a contract like a polite suggestion, but in this industry, your freelance contract termination clauses are the only thing standing between you and a month of unpaid labor. I’ve seen too many talented writers walk away from a three-thousand-word project with nothing but a “thanks for your hard work” because they didn’t specify what happens when the project hits a dead end.

Protecting your livelihood means being clinical about the exit strategy before the first word is even typed. When you are negotiating project cancellation terms, don’t frame it as a penalty; frame it as a way to account for the opportunity cost of the time you’ve already blocked out in your calendar. If a client pulls the plug halfway through a developmental edit, they aren’t just paying for the pages finished—they are paying for the mental real estate you surrendered to their manuscript. You aren’t being difficult; you are being a professional.

Five Ways to Stop Your Bank Account from Bleeding

  • Never, under any circumstances, start a project without a signed contract that explicitly defines the kill fee. If it isn’t in writing, it doesn’t exist, and you’ll spend your afternoon arguing about “fairness” with a client who has already moved on to a cheaper freelancer.
  • Tie your kill fee to milestones, not just the final product. If you’ve completed the outline and the first three chapters, the fee shouldn’t just be a token gesture; it should reflect the specific weight of the labor you’ve already sunk into their project.
  • Stop treating the kill fee like an apology for a failed project. It isn’t a penalty for the client; it is the standard payment for the time you have already spent sweating over a manuscript that they’ve decided they don’t want anymore.
  • Demand a non-refundable deposit upfront. A kill fee is much easier to collect when you already have a portion of the project fee sitting in your account, rather than trying to chase a ghost for a percentage of a total that was never actually paid.
  • Be precise about what “work completed” means in your contract. If the client kills the project halfway through a developmental edit, you need to be able to point to the exact page count or word count that triggered the specific tier of compensation you’re invoicing for.

The Bottom Line on Kill Fees

A kill fee is not a penalty or a negotiation tactic; it is a contractual acknowledgement of the labor you have already performed and the time you can no longer bill to another client.

Never start work without a signed agreement that specifies the percentage of the total fee owed if the project is scrapped, because “we’ll figure it out later” is how freelancers end up working for free.

Treat the kill fee as a non-negotiable line item in your project estimates, ensuring that even if a client’s budget evaporates or their vision shifts, your rent remains covered for the hours already spent.

The Myth of the "Free" Pivot

A kill fee isn’t a penalty for the client; it’s the invoice for the hours you spent building a house they’ve suddenly decided they don’t want to live in. If you aren’t charging for the foundation, you’re essentially donating your labor to their change of heart.

Cressida Farrow-Bassey

The Bottom Line

At the end of the day, a kill fee isn’t about being difficult or squeezing extra blood from a stone; it is about the mathematical reality of your time. We have covered the percentages, the necessity of including these clauses in your initial contract, and how to handle that awkward moment when a client decides to pivot mid-project. If you aren’t charging for the hours you have already poured into a manuscript, you aren’t just being “flexible”—you are effectively subsidizing your client’s indecision with your own rent money. A professional relationship requires that both parties respect the labor behind the words, even when the words never see the light of day.

I know it feels uncomfortable to talk about money when you are in the middle of a creative flow, but please remember that your expertise is a finite resource. You can be the most talented ghostwriter or editor in the room, but talent alone won’t pay the invoice if you haven’t protected your downside. Treat your freelance career like the business it is, not a hobby that happens to pay occasionally. Once you stop viewing these negotiations as personal affronts and start seeing them as standard operating procedure, you will find that you actually have more energy to focus on the work that matters. Protect your margins, and the rest will follow.

About Cressida Farrow-Bassey

Writing is a job with rates, deadlines and invoices, and pretending otherwise keeps people poor. I write about what a copy edit actually costs, why your second draft is worse than your first, how a publishing contract really splits the money, and which parts of this trade have quietly stopped paying at all. I have been on both sides of the desk and I will tell you what editors say about manuscripts when the writer is not in the room.